Now
don't go getting me wrong here, I may agree with quite a bit of what
Mr. Kruiser said, but I am by no means ready to join the right any
time soon. Also, while the article was very good at pointing out why
the left needs to examine its leaders, I don't see the same insight
given to his own political party. While yes, the tea party is indeed
challenging the established Republican leadership, there are still
plenty of dangerous ideas on the right. I am not saying all
ideas on the right are dangerous anymore than the article makes any
claim that all leftist ideas are dangerous. I am saying there are a
few that just like the things pointed out by Mr. Krusier need to be
considered by the left, there are some that the right needs to
consider as well.
Mr.
Kruiser brings up a few examples in his article, and I feel its only
fair if I do the same. The main thrust of the article is that the
Democratic leadership has gone off the deep end and we liberals
should be aware of that. I also believe the same to be true of much
of the Republican leadership and of the incoming Tea Party delegates.
Their combination of hatred for welfare, their willingness to wage
war, and their insistence on not raising taxes on the wealthy are all
very scary things and something they should look at deeply. Just like
liberals have been sold the Koch brothers are behind all evil, the
right has been sold that welfare, taxes, and organized labor are the
root of all evil.
At
one time you could talk to a Republican about the benefits of welfare
and by and large they would agree that there are many. Now, they
would say we spend to much money on it and they would make an
argument that government is the worst organization to handle welfare,
but they would agree it has a benefit. Now if you mention
welfare run the risk of setting of a raging tirade about the
injustice of a socialist draconian welfare state. Why has this
happened? Because just as the left has been brainwashed to believe
that all government is good government, the right is being
brainwashed to believe no government is the best government.
Just
like with the left being hoodwinked, the right is as well and it all
comes down to the media. both sides of he media have turned on the
misinformation like never before and have drifted so far from the
truth that it is almost impossible for us to know exactly what the
truth is. While the right has long held the media is left winged,
they have never wanted to yield to the fact they have their own media
outlets. Currently conservative talk radio dominates the AM band and
is doing nothing but pumping fear and hatred into their listeners.
The cries of socialism and dictatorship have grown louder and louder,
where moderate voices are ridiculed and thrown out for being to
"soft" or "not conservative enough". This has led
to the right going further away from the center than ever before and
just as with the left, is a very dangerous thing.
If
the conservatives succeed in their plan to abolish welfare, taxes,
and organized labor, the face of the U.S. becomes a different place.
We have a great historical context to actually know what this would
look like. At the birth of the industrial era U.S. policy looked a
lot like the dream conservatives are being given, but the reality of
what it looked like is nothing at all like the dream. I am sure some
conservatives believe that for some reason our world would not look
the same as that world, but they are wrong.
While
it is hard for them to accept, the right has to eventually concede
that some government is needed to assure that the field of
opportunity remains as level as possible. This means that not only do
we need to bolster those with less opportunity, but that those with
greater opportunity should bear a greater burden. Ideally we wouldn't
have to do either, and that should be the world we work toward, but
until we are in a world where everyone is truly given equal
opportunity to win or lose, we need to keep the balancing act going.
If
the right continues to pull further and further to the extreme right,
then eventually no matter how moderate the left becomes the cause is
lost. In the same token, the left needs to start working more toward
the middle as well. As an electorate we need to end reactionary
opinions and start looking at our own sides and work to fix what is
wrong there instead of only looking at the opposing side. If we can
do that, if both right and left can work to find their way to middle
ground again, then we have hope.
Conservatives in no way want to get rid of welfare, taxes, or organized labor. Yes there are some extreme voices who might be calling for this but nobody that is worth paying attention too. Hell, even the poster child of the "destroy unions" panic, Scott Walker, only wanted to get rid of unions for employees of the government and he has that great Progressive leader FDR on his side not to mention several past leaders of such unions as the AFL-CIO. Now what conservatives are against is bullshit like card check where union leaders walk the shop floor and ask people if they want a union and then if they claim that the majority said they wanted it then the union is in. What conservatives are for is the secret ballot where every vote counts and every vote is counted, something that liberals made into a bumper sticker slogan during the Florida recount.
ReplyDeleteOn welfare, conservatives are all for it so long as it is targeted and temporary. If you really want to see what welfare would look like under conservatives look at the welfare reform act that was passed and signed into law under Pres. Clinton. Or look at the welfare reform that Pres. Reagan proposed. Under that proposal welfare recipients would continue to receive their benefits but if they were physically and mentally capable then they would have to work for it. This work would be things like picking up trash along the highways, planting trees, or cleaning up graffiti. It is exactly the same in spirit as the New Deal which was and is embraced by liberals but when Reagan proposed it the left called it slavery.
Finally on taxes, conservatives recognize that taxes are needed to fund the government in this day and age we simply believe that we could do with less spending and lower taxes. I mean let's be honest here, this fiscal year the federal government took in more revenue then any other year in our country's history and yet we still have a $649 billion budget deficit.
Exactly my point Dave, you and most conservatives have no desire to completely scrab every single progressive part of our government. However, if you look at the messages that re being shouted the loudest, they are of the extreme "get rid of it all" kind of battle cry and that is who is getting elected right now. Anyway thank you both for reading and taking the time to respond.
Delete